Why Stock Prices Fall After Beating Earnings

Good Evening! 👋

Welcome to Wealth Wednesday!

Here’s What You Missed Last Week:  

1. Powering AI: Top Stocks To Watch

2. How To Spot The Next Big Win

3. Portfolio Changes: December 2024

Dear Investor,

If you’re investing in publicly traded companies, there’s one thing you need to pay close attention to: earnings reports. These quarterly updates provide a snapshot of how a company is performing in the current market environment and whether they’re on track to meet their projections.

Every three months, publicly traded companies are required to publish their earnings. This transparency allows investors like us to evaluate how well a company is doing. But here’s the twist: before these reports are made public, Wall Street analysts issue their own estimates on what they think the company’s performance will look like.

The stakes? Huge.

If a company beats these expectations (commonly called an "earnings beat"), its stock price often surges. But if they fall short, the stock could drop and, sometimes, drop hard.

Here’s the kicker: even when companies crush analyst estimates, their stock price might still tumble.

Why? Well, we’ll get to that in a minute.

But first, let’s dig into the four performance metrics I always keep an eye on during earnings season.

Four Key Metrics to Watch

When it comes to earnings reports, not all numbers are created equal. While there are dozens of metrics you could analyze, here are the four that I always prioritize.

1. Revenue: The Top-Line Number

Revenue, or sales, is the total amount of money a company earns before subtracting any expenses. Think of it as the purest measure of demand for a company’s products or services.

Revenue growth shows whether a company is expanding its customer base or increasing its market share. As an investor, I look for companies that consistently beat revenue estimates because it indicates strong demand.

Let’s talk about Amazon. If Amazon’s revenue for Q1 is $150 billion but analysts expected $140 billion, this is a positive signal. It shows that despite competition and economic conditions, more people are buying from Amazon. But if revenue misses estimates? Investors might start questioning whether the company is losing steam.

Pro Tip: Look for year-over-year (YoY) growth in revenue. Comparing one quarter to the same quarter last year accounts for seasonality and gives a clearer picture of growth.

2. Earnings Per Share (EPS): The Bottom Line

While revenue tells us how much money is coming in, EPS reveals how much profit the company keeps after all expenses are paid. EPS is calculated by dividing net income by the number of outstanding shares.

A higher EPS indicates stronger profitability, which often translates to better growth potential and the ability to reward shareholders through dividends or stock buybacks.

Example:
Apple reported EPS of $1.52 in a recent quarter, beating Wall Street’s estimate of $1.45. This seemingly small difference sent the stock soaring. Why? It signals that Apple is managing costs efficiently and generating solid profits for shareholders.

3. Unit Sales or Subscriptions Gained: The Product Performance Indicator

Unit sales refer to the number of products sold during the quarter. For companies with flagship products, this metric can drive stock price reactions more than revenue or EPS.

Investors often tie a company’s success to the performance of its most popular product. If sales of that product disappoint, the stock could drop even if revenue and EPS beat estimates.

Example:
Take Apple’s iPhone, which accounts for roughly half of the company’s annual revenue. If unit sales of the iPhone fall quarter-over-quarter, investors might panic, fearing declining demand. But here’s the nuance: if Apple increases its average selling price for iPhones, revenue might still grow, offsetting lower unit sales.

4. Free Cash Flow: The Shareholder’s Best Friend

Free cash flow (FCF) is the money a company has left after covering operating expenses and capital expenditures. Think of it as the cash available to reward shareholders or invest in future growth.
Strong free cash flow allows companies to pay dividends, buy back shares, or reinvest in the business.

Personally, FCF is my favorite metric because it directly impacts shareholder value.

Example:
Let’s use Shark Tank’s Mr. Wonderful as an analogy. If Mr. Wonderful owns 10% of a business with $1 million in free cash flow, he earns $100,000 annually in distributions. Similarly, as a shareholder, you want to invest in companies generating positive free cash flow. If a company reports negative FCF, it raises questions about sustainability even if revenue looks impressive.

Why Stocks Drop After an Earnings Beat

Here’s the part that confuses most new investors: a company can absolutely crush expectations for key metrics like revenue, EPS, unit sales, and free cash flow yet still see its stock price plummet. It’s one of those frustrating realities of investing that often feels counterintuitive. Let’s dive deeper into the seven most common reasons this happens.

1. Weak Guidance

Guidance is the company’s forecast for future earnings, revenue, or other key performance metrics. Investors don’t just care about what happened last quarter—they care even more about what’s coming next. Strong guidance can propel a stock higher even if the current quarter was lackluster, while weak guidance can send a stock spiraling downward despite stellar earnings.

Why it matters:
Weak guidance signals uncertainty about the company’s future performance. It may indicate slower growth, challenges in scaling, or external pressures like supply chain issues or economic downturns.

Example:
Imagine Apple releases record-breaking iPhone sales for Q1, far surpassing Wall Street’s expectations. However, during the earnings call, they announced that due to supply chain constraints, Q2 iPhone production will be reduced by 20%. Investors don’t care about the Q1 success anymore; they focus on the potential impact of reduced production on future revenue. As a result, the stock drops.

What to look for:
Pay close attention to the company’s tone during earnings calls and any projections about upcoming quarters. Watch for phrases like “challenging environment” or “revised expectations” as warning signs.

2. Subscriber or User Slowdowns

For subscription-based companies or platforms with large user bases, growth in subscribers or active users is a critical metric. A slowdown in these numbers, even if other metrics like revenue and EPS are strong, can scare investors.

Why it matters:
Subscribers represent future recurring revenue. If user growth stalls, it suggests that the company may struggle to maintain or grow its revenue streams in the long term.

Example:
Netflix is a classic case of subscriber-based metrics driving stock performance. Even when Netflix beats revenue and EPS estimates, a decline in subscriber growth—or worse, a net loss of subscribers—causes investor panic. For instance, in early 2022, Netflix reported earnings that beat expectations but also revealed it had lost subscribers for the first time in over a decade. The result? The stock plummeted.

What to look for:
Dig into the earnings report for user growth numbers and compare them to historical trends. Platforms like Spotify, Snapchat, and Meta rely heavily on this metric, so it’s a key indicator of their health.

3. Management Changes

Leadership changes can shake investor confidence, even when a company posts strong earnings. A respected CEO or executive leaving the company can create uncertainty about the business's direction.

Why it matters:
Strong leadership drives innovation, strategy, and investor trust. When a key leader departs, it often raises questions about why they left and whether the company will maintain its momentum. Imagine if Elon Musk left Tesla.

Example:
When Sheryl Sandberg announced her departure as Meta’s COO, the stock took a hit despite solid earnings. Investors worried about how the company would navigate its next chapter without her steady hand. Conversely, when a poorly performing CEO resigns, the stock can rise. (How embarrassing!)

What to look for:
Pay attention to the reasons behind the departure. Was it planned, or does it hint at deeper problems within the company? Watch for phrases like “pursuing other opportunities” or “stepping aside to spend more time with family,” as these can sometimes be red flags.

4. Questionable Dividend Increases

Dividends are typically seen as a positive sign—a way for companies to reward shareholders. However, if a company increases its dividend when it doesn’t have the cash flow to support it, investors may see it as an unsustainable move.

Why it matters:
A dividend increase during times of financial strain suggests the company is prioritizing shareholder payouts over long-term stability. This can be a desperate attempt to attract investors or maintain confidence.

Example:
Consider a struggling retailer that announces a dividend hike despite negative free cash flow and rising debt. Investors may interpret this as a risky move that puts the company’s financial health in jeopardy, leading to a sell-off.

What to look for:
Compare dividend increases to the company’s cash flow and debt levels. If free cash flow is shrinking or debt is rising, a dividend hike might not be sustainable.

5. Rising Debt Levels

Debt is a necessary tool for growth, but excessive debt can overshadow even the most impressive earnings report. If a company relies too heavily on borrowing to meet expectations, investors may question the sustainability of its growth.

Why it matters:
High debt increases risk, especially in a rising interest rate environment. It limits a company’s flexibility to invest in innovation, weather downturns, or pay dividends.

Example:
Let’s say a company beats revenue and EPS estimates, but analysts discover that it added $2 billion in debt to fund its operations. The stock could drop as investors worry about the long-term implications of this borrowing.

What to look for:
Check the company’s debt-to-equity ratio, interest coverage ratio, and any mention of refinancing in the earnings report. If these metrics are deteriorating, it’s a red flag.

6. Profit-Taking After High Expectations

Sometimes, a stock drops after earnings simply because expectations were too high going into the report. This is known as a “buy the rumor, sell the news” event.

Why it matters:
When investors pile into a stock ahead of earnings, they drive up the price. Even if the earnings report is strong, it might not be enough to justify the inflated valuation, leading to a sell-off.

Example:
Tesla is a prime example. Before earnings, the market often speculates wildly about its potential. When earnings are finally released—even if they beat expectations—investors might sell to lock in profits, causing the stock to dip.

What to look for:
Watch for significant pre-earnings run-ups in stock price. If the stock has climbed sharply in the weeks leading up to the report, a sell-off is more likely, regardless of the actual earnings performance.

7. Misguided Stock Buybacks

Stock buybacks are usually a good sign, as they reduce the number of shares outstanding, increasing earnings per share (EPS). However, if a company initiates buybacks while facing cash flow issues or if its stock is overvalued, it can backfire.

Why it matters:
Misguided buybacks suggest poor capital allocation decisions. Instead of investing in growth or maintaining a cash buffer, the company may be artificially inflating its stock price.

Example:
Imagine a tech company with a high valuation using debt to fund a massive buyback program. While this might boost EPS temporarily, it raises questions about whether the company is over-leveraged or trying to mask underlying issues.

What to look for:
Check the company’s cash flow and debt levels relative to the size of its buyback program. If buybacks are being funded through borrowing, that’s a red flag.

Final Thoughts:

Earnings reports are a treasure trove of information, but interpreting them isn’t always straightforward. By understanding why stocks sometimes drop after earnings beats, you can avoid knee-jerk reactions and make more informed decisions. Remember, the stock market is forward-looking. Strong earnings today won’t matter if the outlook for tomorrow looks shaky.

The key takeaway? Always dig deeper into the numbers and context behind the headlines. This is what separates confident investors from the rest of the pack.

Disclaimer for BeanWealth

BeanWealth is a publisher of financial education and information. We are not an investment advisor and do not provide personalized investment advice or recommendations tailored to any individual's financial situation. The content provided through our website, newsletters, and any other materials is for educational purposes only and should not be construed as financial or investment advice.

All information is provided “as is,” without warranty of any kind. BeanWealth makes no representations or guarantees regarding the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the information presented. The opinions and views expressed in our content are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of BeanWealth, its partners, or its affiliates.

Investors should perform their own due diligence and consult with a professional financial advisor before making any investment decisions. None of the information provided herein constitutes a solicitation to buy or sell any securities or financial instruments. Any projections or forecasts mentioned are speculative and subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual outcomes to differ.

BeanWealth, its employees, and affiliates may hold positions (long or short) in the securities or companies mentioned, and these positions may change without notice. No guarantees are made regarding the continuation of these positions.

Forward-looking statements, estimates, or forecasts provided are inherently uncertain and based on assumptions that may not occur. Other unforeseen factors may arise that could materially affect the actual outcomes or performance of the securities discussed. BeanWealth has no obligation to update or correct any information after the date of publication.

BeanWealth disclaims any liability for losses or damages, whether direct or indirect, resulting from the use of the information provided. By accessing or using any BeanWealth content, you agree to this disclaimer and our terms of service.

Unauthorized distribution, reproduction, or sharing of this content is strictly prohibited and subject to legal action.